Whether you're new to coin collecting or already building a serious portfolio, one question comes up constantly:
Should I buy raw coins or graded coins?
Both options can be excellent—if you know what you're doing. As dealers who evaluate thousands of coins each year, we have seen collectors win big (and lose big) by choosing one over the other. This guide breaks down the differences, the advantages, the risks, and how to decide what’s right for your goals.
What Are Raw vs. Graded Coins?
Raw Coins
A raw coin is simply a coin that has not been certified by a third-party grading service like PCGS, NGC, ANACS, or ICG.
You evaluate it based on:
- Eye appeal
- Wear
- Strike
- Surfaces
- Luster
- Any problems (cleaning, scratches, PVC residue, etc.)
Graded Coins
A graded coin has been professionally authenticated and graded by a third-party service. It comes in a tamper-evident slab with:
- A numerical grade (PR/MS 1–70)
- A QR code
- Verification number
- Attribution details
Certified coins often include CAC approval, indicating premium quality for the grade.
Advantages of Buying Graded Coins
1. Guaranteed Authenticity
The biggest advantage: You’re not gambling. PCGS and NGC take counterfeits seriously, and their holders give collectors peace of mind.
2. Market-Recognized Grade
Graded coins eliminate arguments about condition. MS65 is MS65—period. This standardization makes pricing easier and increases liquidity.
3. Stronger Investment Potential
High-grade certified coins typically:
- Maintain value better
- Appreciate more predictably
- Sell faster
This is especially true for rare coins, key dates, and high-value pieces.
4. CAC Adds an Extra Layer
Coins with CAC approval often command premiums because they’re the top quality within their grade.
5. Online Buyers Prefer Graded
If you plan to sell on eBay or other platforms, slabs convert better. They remove risk for the buyer.
Advantages of Buying Raw Coins
1. Lower Price Entry Point
Raw coins are almost always cheaper than their graded equivalents.
This can be a big advantage if:
- You’re building a set
- You’re buying lower-value coins
- You’re collecting for enjoyment more than investment
2. Opportunity to Find Undervalued Pieces
Experienced collectors sometimes grade raw coins to capture added value. For example, if someone buys a raw coin priced like XF, but it grades AU, that guarantees profit. But this requires strong grading skill (or a trusted dealer).
3. More Freedom to Handle, View, and Study
Raw coins can be:
- Placed in albums
- Held (carefully!)
- Examined without plastic in the way
This makes them more fun for many collectors, especially beginners.
4. Perfect for Bulk Silver and Lower-Value Items
There’s no need to slab:
- 1964 quarters
- Common-date Morgans in XF/AU
- Modern bullion
- Junk silver
Raw is ideal for items where grading fees outweigh the value.
Risks of Raw Coins (And How to Avoid Them)
1. Overgrading
Most raw coins on the market are optimistically graded—sometimes by one full level or more.
2. Hidden Problems
Raw coins may have:
- Cleaning
- Scratches
- Dulling
- Hairlines
- PVC
- Dips
- Altered surfaces
In a slab, you know exactly what you’re buying.
3. Counterfeits
Raw coins—especially key dates—are a minefield of fakes.
Buying raw coins from trusted dealers like Beantown Coins eliminates this risk.
So… Which Should You Buy?
The answer depends on your goals.
Buy Graded Coins If You Want…
- Long-term investment
- Key dates or rarities
- High-value purchases
- Peace of mind
- Easy resale
- Registry set collecting
Best for:
Serious collectors, investors, and anyone buying scarce, expensive, or condition-sensitive coins.
Buy Raw Coins If You Want…
- Lower entry prices
- Hands-on collecting experience
- Filling album sets
- Buying bullion, junk silver, or common dates
- Hunting for submission candidates
Best for:
Beginners, album collectors, budget buyers, and experienced graders hunting gems.
The Dealer’s Rule of Thumb
Here’s the quick takeaway from years of buying, selling, and grading:
If the coin’s value heavily depends on condition → buy graded.
If the coin’s value is mostly intrinsic or modest → buy raw.
Final Thoughts: There’s No “Wrong” Choice—Just the Right Choice for You!
Raw and graded coins both have a place in every collection. Graded coins protect your investment, while raw coins maximize enjoyment and affordability. Many of the best collectors blend both. If you’re unsure which route to take, or need help evaluating a raw coin’s potential, Beantown Coins is here to guide you—whether you’re investing, learning, or building a legacy collection!
Beantown Coins & Jewelry
Buy. Sell. Trade. Appraise.